Generative AI can bypass the very practice that builds learning.

AI tools can answer instantly, but the struggle of retrieving, reasoning, and correcting mistakes is what actually builds durable learning. When students outsource that struggle to a chatbot, the practice that makes learning stick may never happen.

How learning happens

1
Retrieve

Access what you know

2
Reason

Make sense and plan

3
Attempt

Try a solution, even if hard

4
Feedback

Notice mistakes and learn

5
Revise

Adjust and improve

Retrieval-practice source: Carpenter, Pan & Butler (2022), Nature Reviews Psychology, 1, 496–511.

Childhood is a critical time for brain development

Extensive refinement

Frontal-cortex synaptic density changes substantially through childhood and adolescence.

"Use it or lose it"

Neural activity helps shape which connections are maintained and which are eliminated.

What we do not know

The developmental effects of routinely outsourcing cognitive practice to generative AI remain unclear.

Huttenlocher (1979), Brain Research, 163, 195–205; Faust, Gunner & Schafer (2021), Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 22, 657–673.

The nation's two largest school districts have paused student access to generative AI

On September 2, 2026, LAUSD and NYC announced pauses on student access to generative AI. Both are using this time to build safeguards for introducing AI safely and effectively.

NYC Mayor's Office (Sept. 2, 2026); K–12 Dive (Sept. 3, 2026).

Let's build on national momentum

Help SMFCSD get this right

Learn ways parents, teachers, and PTAs can help. Share the website. Bring another parent into the effort.

Add my signature